The short answer
A Microsoft 365 security review is an independent check of how your Microsoft 365 is set up. That covers logins, admin accounts, email, sharing, connected apps, logs and backup.
A good one gives you six things. Findings, evidence, risk, priority, fixes and a roadmap.
Your Microsoft Secure Score is one input. It isn’t the answer, and Microsoft says so itself.
Written by Jumei Lin, founder of Lumeio, working with the team at SouthEast IT on Microsoft 365 security for Australian businesses.
Find out what your Secure Score isn't telling you
Find the gaps your Secure Score can’t see. SouthEast IT shows you the evidence for each one, and what to fix first, in plain English. Start with a Microsoft 365 security review.
Your Microsoft Secure Score is 78%. Nice. But a good score doesn’t mean you’re secure. It’s a bit like buying a house off the listing photos. Everything looks amazing, because the photographer knows exactly where to stand. The building and pest inspection is the boring bit. It tells you the back deck is held up by two bricks and a lot of optimism. A Microsoft 365 security review is that inspection. [Picks up clipboard.]
This guide covers what a good review should actually hand you, and how to spot one that’s just a printout. In plain English, with as few acronyms as I can manage.
What this guide covers
- What is a Microsoft 365 security review?
- Is Microsoft Secure Score enough?
- What should a Microsoft 365 security review produce?
- What does one good finding look like?
- How do you prioritise Microsoft 365 security findings?
- What does a Microsoft 365 security assessment check?
- Is backup part of a Microsoft 365 security review?
- What does a 90 day remediation roadmap look like?
- Five signs your Microsoft 365 security audit isn’t a real one
160+
Microsoft 365 security settings the WA Auditor General checked in each agency, in its 2026 report
5 of 10 points
What Secure Score awards for MFA on half your users, in Microsoft’s own example
180 days
How long Audit (Standard) keeps Microsoft 365 audit records on most non-E5 licences
$56,600
Average self-reported cost per cybercrime report for a small business, FY2024-25 (ASD)
01
What is a Microsoft 365 security review?
A Microsoft 365 security review is a structured check of your tenant’s settings, logins, admin access, email protection, sharing, connected apps, logging and backup. It ends with evidence based findings, ranked by risk, and a practical plan to fix them. Some providers call it a Microsoft 365 security assessment or a Microsoft 365 security audit. Older guides still say Office 365 security review. Same idea, newer name.
Quick translation first, because we IT people love a word nobody else uses.
Your tenant is your business’s own slice of Microsoft 365. All your users, mailboxes, files and settings live there. For this guide, it’s the house.
A good inspector doesn’t just count the light switches. They check the roof, the wiring and the stumps. Then they tell you what to fix before you move in.
Here’s how a review stacks up against the Microsoft Secure Score you’ve already got.
| Microsoft Secure Score | A proper security review | |
|---|---|---|
| Who produces it | Microsoft, automatically | An independent reviewer |
| What it measures | How many recommended actions you’ve taken | How exposed your business actually is |
| What it covers | Supported products, but not every attack surface | Your whole tenant, including how people use it |
| Context | The same recommendations for everyone | Your licences, your people, your risks |
| What you get | A score and a to do list | Findings, evidence, priorities and a roadmap |
| Best used as | A baseline | A decision making tool |
If you’d like the basics first, our small business cyber security checklist covers the controls every business should have. A review checks whether those controls actually work in your tenant.
What an independent audit found
In a report published in March 2026, the Western Australian Auditor General checked seven state government agencies against more than 160 Microsoft 365 security settings.
The verdict. The agencies were “only partly effective” at managing and configuring Microsoft 365.
All seven had poor data sharing controls, and didn’t consistently block high-risk sign-ins, like logins from unusual places or unknown devices.
At least five hadn’t backed up their security settings.
These are government agencies with IT teams and security policies. The Auditor General also noted that many of the gaps were relatively easy and inexpensive to fix.
So if you run a 20 person business and nobody has looked, it’s fair to assume some of the same gaps until someone checks.
02
Is Microsoft Secure Score enough?
No. Microsoft Secure Score is a useful baseline, but Microsoft says it isn’t an absolute measure of how likely you are to be breached. Its recommendations don’t cover every attack surface either. A proper review uses the score as one input, then adds evidence, context and priorities.
Secure Score is the listing photo. It’s real, and it’s useful. It’s just taken at golden hour, with the bins wheeled out of shot.
Here’s how the points work. Each recommended action is worth up to 10 points. You can earn some of them for doing part of the job.
Microsoft’s own example uses MFA, the extra code from your phone after your password. Turn it on for 50 of your 100 users and you get 5 of the 10 points.
So a respectable score can still hide 50 people with no MFA.
There’s another way to pick up points. You can mark an action as handled by another tool, and Microsoft has no visibility into whether that’s true. It takes your word for it.
You can also accept a risk and skip an action. Both are fine when there’s a real reason. A review checks the reason actually exists, and isn’t a sticky note that says “sorted”.
Paying for the security tools isn’t the same as switching them on, either.
In its 2024-25 cyber threat report, the ASD said many federal government organisations “subscribed to an E5 licence, but either did not use or had not optimised existing security products within the licence.”
E5 is Microsoft’s top enterprise plan. If agencies can pay for it and leave the tools idle, a small business on Business Premium can too. A review shows what you already own and what’s actually turned on.
A real example from our team. A professional services firm with 45 users came to us after their cyber insurer raised concerns.
On paper, they felt fine. Most of us do, right up until the insurer rings.
Before the review
MFA was on for some users. Basic spam filtering was running.
But MFA wasn’t enforced on every admin account. Legacy authentication, the old sign-in methods that can’t do MFA, was still switched on.
There were no Conditional Access policies either. Those are the rules that decide who can sign in, from where and on what.
Microsoft Secure Score below 45%.
60 days later
Every admin account protected.
Old sign-in methods blocked.
Microsoft Secure Score at 78%.
The score went up because the real gaps got closed. Not the other way round.
Their Microsoft Secure Score was the receipt, not the goal. The full case study is on our Microsoft 365 security page.
What good looks like
Secure Score used as a baseline. Every risk accepted or alternate mitigation status has a written reason, and the report explains what the score can’t see.
Red flag
The report is a Secure Score screenshot with Microsoft’s recommendations pasted underneath.
That’s not an inspection. That’s a printout.
Straight from Microsoft
Secure score shouldn’t be interpreted as a guarantee against security breach in any manner.
Microsoft Learn · Microsoft Secure Score documentation
03
What should a Microsoft 365 security review produce?
A good security review should produce six things. Findings, evidence, risk, priority, remediation and a roadmap. Miss any one and you’re left with a list of problems and no idea what to do on Monday.
Here’s the order, using the house as the example.
Reviewer
Findings
What’s wrong. In the house, the roof leaks. In Microsoft 365, two admin accounts have no MFA.
Reviewer
Evidence
How we know. A photo of the water stain. A policy export showing exactly which accounts are left out.
Reviewer
Risk
Why it matters. Water near the wiring. One stolen admin password could open the whole tenant.
You and the reviewer
Priority
What gets fixed first. The roof before the paint. Admin accounts before the guest list.
Reviewer
Remediation
What should change, specifically. Replace the flashing. Enforce MFA on every admin role.
You and the reviewer
Roadmap
Who does what, and when. Roof this month, gutters next month, then a second inspection.
Notice that evidence comes second. No evidence, no finding.
A finding without proof is just an opinion with a logo on it.
04
What does one good finding look like?
A good finding names the problem, shows the proof, explains the business risk and gives a specific fix. A weak finding just repeats a best practice. The difference decides whether your team can act on the report, or has to start the investigation again.
Here’s the same problem written two ways, the way it might show up in a Microsoft 365 security assessment report. It’s a made up example, not a real client.
A useful finding
Finding. MFA isn’t enforced for 3 of 7 admin accounts.
Evidence. The Conditional Access policy excludes a group those three accounts belong to. Policy export attached.
Risk. One phished admin password could give an attacker control of the whole tenant.
Fix. Remove the exclusion and require phishing-resistant MFA for admin roles. Keep two emergency access accounts.
Red flag
MFA should be enabled.
That’s it. That’s the whole finding.
Microsoft recommends phishing-resistant MFA for at least 14 admin roles, including Global Administrator and Helpdesk Administrator. That’s MFA a fake login page can’t trick, like a passkey or a physical security key.
It also recommends two emergency access accounts and keeping the number of admins small. Emergency access accounts are the spare key in the lockbox, for the day everything else locks you out.
A good finding ties back to guidance like this. Nobody has to take the reviewer’s word for it.
05
How do you prioritise Microsoft 365 security findings?
Rank each finding by how likely it is to be exploited, how bad the damage would be and how exposed it is. Then group the fixes into three tiers. If everything in a report is marked high priority, nothing is.
An inspector doesn’t put a cracked tile and a sagging roof beam in the same column.
Priority 1
Fix now. Gaps that could hand an attacker the keys.
Think admin accounts without strong MFA, old sign-in methods left on, or email quietly auto forwarding to outside addresses.
Priority 2
Fix soon. Gaps that make you easier to get into.
Oversharing in SharePoint, app permissions nobody has checked, guest accounts nobody remembers inviting. Nobody knows who “temp.user.2019” is.
Priority 3
Plan for it. Housekeeping and governance.
Labelling sensitive data, tidier policies, keeping logs for longer. Important, just not this week.
Effort matters too. A high risk, low effort fix jumps straight to the top.
Those are the quick wins in any review. Do them first and the rest of the list looks a lot less scary.
06
What does a Microsoft 365 security assessment check?
A Microsoft 365 security assessment should check five areas. Identity and admin access, email, collaboration and sharing, connected apps, and logging. Each one fails in a different way, which is why a single score can’t sum them up.
Think of these as the rooms of the house. Here’s what a Microsoft 365 security assessment checks in each, and why.
Identity and access
Who can get in, and how.
MFA for every user. Stronger MFA for admins. How many admin accounts exist (fewer is better). Old sign-in methods, guests and accounts nobody uses any more.
If someone steals a login, this is the door they walk through. So this room gets inspected first.
Microsoft says MFA plus blocking the old sign-in methods stops more than 99.9% of common identity attacks. Two settings. That’s the best return on anything in this list.
What gets in, and what quietly goes out.
Anti-phishing and malware filters. SPF, DKIM and DMARC, three settings that help stop scammers sending email pretending to be you.
Email is the most reported problem. In 2024-25, the most common cybercrime businesses reported to the ASD was email compromise where no money was lost (19% of reports). Second was business email compromise fraud where money was lost (15%).
Microsoft recommends turning off automatic external forwarding. Attackers love hidden inbox rules that quietly send anything mentioning an invoice to their own account. It’s a mail redirect you never signed up for.
In one WA agency, an attacker sat in a senior officer’s mailbox for a month. They set up forwarding rules to hide the replies, then sent fake invoices and approved the payments. The bill was $71,000.
Teams, SharePoint and OneDrive
Who can see your files.
External sharing, guest access and oversharing. An Anyone link lets anyone open a file without signing in. It’s the key under the doormat, with a little sign pointing at the doormat.
Copilot, Microsoft’s AI assistant, works within the permissions people already have. So its exposure risk grows with every person who has access. Worth tidying before you switch it on.
Apps and OAuth consent
Which outside apps you’ve let in.
Third party apps that have been given access to mail and files. OAuth consent is that “Allow this app to read your mail” box people click without reading.
In an illicit consent grant, a dodgy app gets that access. Microsoft notes that resetting passwords or requiring MFA won’t stop the attack, because the app isn’t a user. It’s like changing the locks while the dodgy tradie still has the garage remote.
Our guide to identity threat detection and response explains how these get spotted.
Logging and monitoring
Who’s watching.
What gets recorded, who can see it and whether anyone actually looks. On most licences, Audit (Standard) keeps records for 180 days.
That’s short. The WA Auditor General notes the ASD recommends keeping logs for at least 18 months, three times as long. Without them, you can’t work out what an attacker touched.
Configuration isn’t detection. Detection isn’t response. A review checks all three.
Logs nobody reads are a smoke alarm in an empty house.
Which benchmark should a review use?
A good review names the standard it checks against, so you can check the checker.
CIS Microsoft 365 Foundations Benchmark. A setting by setting list from the Center for Internet Security. Version 7.0.0 is current.
CISA’s SCuBA baselines. Secure settings from the US cyber security agency, with a free tool called ScubaGear that checks a tenant against them.
ASD’s Blueprint for Secure Cloud. The Australian government’s own Microsoft 365 configuration guidance. Written mainly for government, so it’s dry, but solid.
The WA Auditor General used all three, plus Microsoft’s own guides.
A free tool like ScubaGear is a good start. It shows which settings differ from the baseline. It can’t tell you which gaps matter most for your business. That part is the reviewer’s job.
07
Is backup part of a Microsoft 365 security review?
It should be. Security controls try to stop bad things happening. Backup decides how fast you recover when they happen anyway. A good review should check what’s backed up, how long it’s kept and whether anyone has tested a restore.
Security is the locks. Backup is the insurance. And like most insurance, nobody reads the policy until it hails.
Microsoft sells Microsoft 365 Backup for exactly this. It’s for recovering from ransomware, or from files deleted by accident or on purpose.
It’s a separate, pay as you go product, billed by how much data it protects. So don’t assume you already have it. It’s an easy mistake, because it sounds like something that comes free.
A review should ask five plain questions.
- Which mailboxes, SharePoint sites and OneDrives are covered?
- How far back can you restore?
- How long would a full restore take?
- When did someone last test one?
- Are your security settings backed up too?
That last one catches people out. At least five of the seven agencies in the WA audit hadn’t backed up their Microsoft 365 configuration. So a bad change, accidental or malicious, couldn’t be quickly rolled back.
We’ve written more on why Microsoft 365 needs a backup, and on how to test your incident response plan so recovery isn’t a guessing game.
Find out if you could restore Microsoft 365 by Friday
Our managed security bundles can include Microsoft 365 backups for email, SharePoint and OneDrive, alongside email filtering, MFA and endpoint protection. Know what you’d get back, and how fast.
08
What does a 90 day remediation roadmap look like?
A remediation roadmap turns findings into a schedule. Fix the biggest identity gaps first, then strengthen email and sharing, then improve governance and test recovery. Finish by reassessing, so you can show the risk actually went down.
Here’s an example. Your timing depends on what the review finds, your licences and how busy your team is.
IT provider
Days 0 to 30
Close the urgent gaps. Admin MFA, old sign-in methods, risky app permissions and outside access nobody needs.
IT provider
Days 30 to 60
Tighten email and sharing settings. Add Conditional Access policies. Turn on alerts someone will actually read.
Business and IT
Days 60 to 90
Tidy up data governance, agree who reviews what, and run a real restore test.
Business and IT
Reassess
Check every finding is closed or has a written reason. Then compare your Microsoft Secure Score with where you started.
What the fixes cost, in Australian dollars
Plenty of fixes cost nothing but time.
Security defaults, Microsoft’s basic MFA settings, are free on every plan. They also block the old sign-in methods.
Some fixes need a better licence. Conditional Access needs Microsoft Entra ID P1, and Business Premium includes it.
Say the review recommends that upgrade for 20 users. Business Standard is AU$21.00 per user per month and Business Premium is AU$32.90. That’s AU$238 more a month, or AU$2,856 a year.
For scale, the ASD put the average reported cybercrime cost for a small business at AU$56,600 in 2024-25.
Prices are per user per month, paid yearly, exclude GST and come from Microsoft’s Australian pricing pages as at October 2026.
The point of all this
The goal isn’t a perfect score. It’s less of the risk that actually matters to your business.
SouthEast IT · Parkdale, Victoria
09
Five signs your Microsoft 365 security audit isn't a real one
Some Microsoft 365 security audit reports are a building inspection done from the car. Watch for these five.
- You only got a Secure Score screenshot. That’s the listing photo again.
- Every finding is high priority. Then none of them are.
- There’s no evidence. No exports, no screenshots, no settings. Just opinions.
- Nothing explains the business impact. Legacy authentication means little to a finance manager until someone explains what it could cost.
- There’s no roadmap or follow-up. A PDF nobody opens again isn’t a review. It’s a souvenir.
A Microsoft 365 security audit is narrower than a full IT audit.
If you need servers, networks and devices checked too, that’s a full IT audit. Our guide to IT audits versus cyber security assessments explains the difference.
Separately, some providers offer a free Microsoft 365 assessment. It can be a good start. Just check what’s in scope before you book.
A free assessment usually
- covers your Microsoft 365 tenant only
- leaves the fixes out of scope
- ends with a quote for that work
So ask before you book
- Will every finding come with evidence?
- Will the roadmap be ranked by risk?
- Who does the fixes, and what do they cost?
- What access do you need? Read-only should be enough.
From SouthEast IT
What our Microsoft 365 security review includes
We review your tenant and give you
- A Microsoft 365 tenant health check
- A Secure Score review and improvement plan
- An identity and access risk assessment
- A Microsoft Purview configuration review (Purview is Microsoft’s toolkit for finding and protecting sensitive data)
- A clear, prioritised remediation roadmap
No jargon, and no unnecessary upselling. See our Microsoft 365 security services for the details.
A good-looking score might be great. It might also be hiding 50 people without MFA. The only way to know is to look under the house.
So expect six things from any Microsoft 365 security review. Findings, evidence, risk, priority, fixes and a roadmap. Then hold your reviewer to all six. [Puts clipboard down. Inspection complete.]
Know your Microsoft 365 security score. Know your actual risks.
We’ll review your Microsoft 365 environment and turn what we find into a prioritised roadmap. You’ll know what needs attention now, what can wait and what happens next.
Frequently asked questions
What should a Microsoft 365 security review report contain?
At minimum, the scope of the review, each finding with supporting evidence, the business risk, a priority, a specific fix and a remediation roadmap. A short executive summary up front lets owners and managers see what matters without reading every technical detail.
Does MFA make Microsoft 365 secure?
MFA is one of the most important controls. Microsoft says MFA plus blocking legacy sign-in methods stops more than 99.9% of common identity attacks. But it isn’t enough on its own. Microsoft notes that in an illicit consent grant attack, resetting passwords or requiring MFA doesn’t help, because a malicious app holds the access, not a user. A proper review checks identity, email, sharing, apps and logging together.
What access does a Microsoft 365 security review need?
Usually read-only access. Microsoft’s Global Reader role can read everything a Global Administrator can, but can’t change anything. So a reviewer can see your settings without being able to break them. Ask what they’ll export, how they’ll store it, and remove the access when the review ends. Fixing things is a separate step with separate permissions.
Does Microsoft 365 include backup?
Microsoft 365 has built-in resilience and retention features, but Microsoft 365 Backup is a separate, pay as you go product. Many businesses use a third party backup instead. A Microsoft 365 security assessment should confirm what’s covered, how far back you can restore and whether a restore has been tested.
How much does a Microsoft 365 security review cost in Australia?
It depends on the provider and the scope. Some offer a free assessment, but the fixes are usually out of scope and quoted separately. A full review takes longer, because someone checks the evidence and writes a roadmap, so ask for a fixed quote in Australian dollars. Budget for the fixes too. For example, moving 20 users from Business Standard to Business Premium adds AU$2,856 a year, excluding GST, at Microsoft’s October 2026 prices.

Jumei Lin is the founder of Lumeio, a Melbourne-based AI decision and automation consultancy. Lumeio built the ticket triage system that sits behind SEIT’s operational workflow, handling sentiment detection and technician scoring before a human ever touches the ticket. She works with SMEs across Australia on similar problems, where a small amount of automation removes a lot of manual triage.


